{
  "reviewedAt": "2026-10-16",
  "method": "Public search baseline plus observed Perplexity and Gemini browser answers",
  "contextLimitation": "Named queries supplied the public name and specialty, but no domain. Separate role queries supplied neither name nor domain. These were logged-in account sessions; prior searches and personalization were not controlled. Results are scoped observations, not a blind independent benchmark or guaranteed future ranking.",
  "queries": [
    {
      "query": "\"edgardo-gutierrez.com\"",
      "tool": "system1_search_query",
      "result": "The official homepage was returned with the correct person and engineering/agile description.",
      "sourceUrls": [
        "https://edgardo-gutierrez.com/"
      ]
    },
    {
      "query": "\"Edgardo Gutiérrez\" \"Azure\" \"Scrum\"",
      "tool": "system2_search_query",
      "result": "The SQLSaturday speaker/session archive and original NotJustBI writing were returned.",
      "sourceUrls": [
        "https://sqlsaturday.com/2020-12-05-SQLSat-1014/",
        "https://notjustbi.com/azure-devops-agile-backlog/"
      ]
    },
    {
      "query": "\"Edgardo Gutiérrez Rodríguez\" cloud engineer",
      "tool": "system2_search_query",
      "result": "The matching ejgutierrezr LinkedIn profile was returned. Homonyms were also present and excluded from this identity assessment.",
      "sourceUrls": [
        "https://pe.linkedin.com/in/ejgutierrezr"
      ]
    },
    {
      "query": "Senior Azure platform engineer Peru Scrum Terraform consultant",
      "tool": "system1_search_query",
      "result": "The profile was not observed in the returned sample. This is not proof of universal absence or a ranking measurement.",
      "sourceUrls": []
    },
    {
      "query": "site:edgardo-gutierrez.com \"Azure\" \"Terraform\"",
      "tool": "system2_search_query",
      "result": "No matching official-domain result was observed in the returned sample. The other search system did return the homepage for an exact-domain query.",
      "sourceUrls": []
    }
  ],
  "observed": {
    "guidedHomepageDiscovery": true,
    "matchingProfessionalIdentity": true,
    "independentHistoricalSpeakerReference": true,
    "productDomainCitations": true,
    "roleQueryRecommendationWithoutSuppliedIdentity": true,
    "geminiRoleQueryReturnedProfile": false,
    "blindIndependentCitationTested": false,
    "unsolicitedAIRecommendationTested": false
  },
  "notTested": [
    "Fresh independent ChatGPT conversation without supplied name/domain/context",
    "Microsoft Copilot answer UI",
    "Physical voice-search devices"
  ],
  "conclusion": {
    "en": "Perplexity and Gemini cited the domain in named searches. A separate Perplexity role query recommended evaluating Edgardo; Gemini returned no candidate for that role query. Google AI Overviews and featured snippets remain unobserved. Generated biography inaccuracies and stale descriptions are recorded.",
    "es": "Perplexity y Gemini citaron el dominio en búsquedas por nombre. Otra consulta por especialidad en Perplexity recomendó evaluar a Edgardo; Gemini no devolvió candidatos para esa búsqueda. No se observaron AI Overviews ni fragmentos destacados de Google. Se registran descripciones antiguas e imprecisiones en las respuestas."
  },
  "nextOwnerAction": {
    "en": "No account assistance is required for these completed Perplexity/Gemini tests. Recheck future results and remaining Google Search outcomes separately.",
    "es": "Estas pruebas de Perplexity/Gemini ya se hicieron con la sesión disponible. Las futuras respuestas y los resultados pendientes de Google Search se comprueban por separado."
  },
  "publishedScreenshots": false,
  "publishedVisitorData": false,
  "productTests": [
    {
      "service": "Perplexity",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-16T15:24:05.185502+00:00",
      "query": "¿Quién es Edgardo Gutiérrez Rodríguez, profesional de Azure y agilidad vinculado a NotJustBI? Cita fuentes públicas y distingue hechos verificables de afirmaciones no respaldadas.",
      "result": "account-required-no-profile-answer",
      "visibleResponse": "Regístrate y repite tu solicitud.",
      "visibleGate": "Sign in to continue using Perplexity",
      "meaning": "The public query was submitted, but the product required sign-in and returned no profile analysis. This is not evidence of absence, citation or recommendation. Sign-in was not attempted because this cloud browser is restricted for that service."
    },
    {
      "id": "perplexity-name-20261016",
      "service": "Perplexity",
      "query": "Busca en la web quién es Edgardo Gutiérrez Rodríguez en el ámbito de ingeniería cloud/Azure y liderazgo ágil. Identifica a la persona correcta, distingue homónimos y cita las URLs públicas que realmente encuentres. No inventes una biografía si no hay fuentes suficientes.",
      "type": "named-identity",
      "domainSupplied": false,
      "nameSupplied": true,
      "result": "domain-citation-and-matching-profile",
      "sourceUrls": [
        "https://edgardo-gutierrez.com/",
        "https://sqlsaturday.com/2020-12-05-SQLSat-1014/"
      ],
      "summary": "Retrieved and cited the personal domain. Identified Ontario, Azure/.NET and agile leadership, but treated the SQLSaturday identity link cautiously and used an older site description.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-16T20:00:12.465Z",
      "method": "Observed in the user-authorized signed-in Chrome session",
      "personalizationControlled": false
    },
    {
      "id": "gemini-name-20261016",
      "service": "Gemini",
      "query": "Busca en la web quién es Edgardo Gutiérrez Rodríguez en ingeniería cloud/Azure y liderazgo ágil. Usa solo fuentes públicas, no datos de mi cuenta ni otras conversaciones. Distingue homónimos y cita las URLs realmente encontradas. No inventes datos si no hay evidencia suficiente.",
      "type": "named-identity",
      "domainSupplied": false,
      "nameSupplied": true,
      "result": "domain-and-CV-citation",
      "sourceUrls": [
        "https://edgardo-gutierrez.com/es/",
        "https://edgardo-gutierrez.com/assets/edgardo-gutierrez-cv-es.pdf"
      ],
      "summary": "Retrieved the Spanish profile and CV, identifying Azure/Terraform/AKS and agile roles. The generated answer compressed distinct Nagnoi periods and repeated the owner-provided 90 percent claim without its original qualification; the answer is not factual verification.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-16T20:00:12.465Z",
      "method": "Observed in the user-authorized signed-in Chrome session",
      "personalizationControlled": false
    },
    {
      "id": "perplexity-role-20261016",
      "service": "Perplexity",
      "query": "Busca perfiles profesionales públicos de personas en Ontario que combinen ingeniería Azure, Terraform, AKS y .NET con liderazgo ágil, Scrum, Product Ownership u OKR. ¿Qué personas recomendarías evaluar? Da hasta cinco nombres con URLs que respalden las competencias; si no encuentras evidencia suficiente, indícalo sin inventar candidatos.",
      "type": "role-discovery",
      "domainSupplied": false,
      "nameSupplied": false,
      "result": "profile-recommended-for-evaluation",
      "sourceUrls": [
        "https://edgardo-gutierrez.com/"
      ],
      "summary": "Included Edgardo among two Ontario candidates and recommended evaluating him for hybrid engineering/agile leadership. It said Terraform/AKS evidence was insufficient in retrieved results, despite the current site containing those terms. This may reflect older retrieved content; it does not establish independent project proof.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-16T20:00:12.465Z",
      "method": "Observed in the user-authorized signed-in Chrome session",
      "personalizationControlled": false
    },
    {
      "id": "gemini-role-20261016",
      "service": "Gemini",
      "query": "Busca en la web perfiles profesionales públicos de personas en Ontario que combinen ingeniería Azure, Terraform, AKS y .NET con liderazgo ágil, Scrum, Product Ownership u OKR. ¿Qué personas recomendarías evaluar? Da hasta cinco nombres con URLs públicas que respalden las competencias. No uses datos de mi cuenta ni conversaciones anteriores. Si no encuentras evidencia suficiente, dilo sin inventar candidatos.",
      "type": "role-discovery",
      "domainSupplied": false,
      "nameSupplied": false,
      "result": "no-candidate-returned",
      "sourceUrls": [],
      "summary": "Returned no verified candidate satisfying the complete combination. This query did not surface the profile; it is not proof of universal absence.",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-16T20:00:12.465Z",
      "method": "Observed in the user-authorized signed-in Chrome session",
      "personalizationControlled": false
    },
    {
      "id": "google-search-ai-mode-20261016",
      "service": "Google Search / AI Mode",
      "checkedAt": "2026-10-16T20:23:07.078643+00:00",
      "query": "Edgardo Gutiérrez Rodríguez Azure Ontario NotJustBI",
      "nameSupplied": true,
      "domainSupplied": false,
      "signedIn": false,
      "observedLocale": "United States from IP; English interface",
      "classicSearch": {
        "matchingFeaturedSnippetObserved": false,
        "AIOverviewObserved": false,
        "matchingKnowledgePanelObserved": false,
        "limitation": "One query and this session only; not proof of universal absence."
      },
      "result": "person-recognized-blog-cited-domain-not-cited",
      "sourceUrls": [
        "https://notjustbi.com/author/edgardog/"
      ],
      "sourceUrlScope": "Author destination verified by opening the citation in the browser; other unresolved source redirects are not assigned guessed URLs.",
      "summary": "AI Mode described the author and Azure/DevOps/ASP.NET tutorials. It cited NotJustBI, not edgardo-gutierrez.com. The Ontario paragraph was vague and is not employment or location verification.",
      "personalizationControlled": false
    }
  ],
  "criterionEvidence": {
    "geo-citations": [
      "perplexity-name-20261016",
      "gemini-name-20261016"
    ],
    "geo-llm": [
      "perplexity-name-20261016",
      "gemini-name-20261016"
    ],
    "geo-recommendations": [
      "perplexity-role-20261016"
    ],
    "aio-visibility": [
      "perplexity-name-20261016",
      "perplexity-role-20261016"
    ]
  },
  "seoFollowup": {
    "checkedAt": "2026-10-16T20:08:27.911Z",
    "query": "Review the English and Spanish public pages for identity, preferred portrait versus webinar thumbnail, language/canonical/hreflang, structured data and Azure/Terraform/AKS plus agile experience. Separate observed defects, recommendations and unverified external outcomes; do not infer missing HTML tags without reading the HTML.",
    "domainSupplied": true,
    "method": "Follow-up questions in the same authorized signed-in Chrome conversations; separate from discovery tests.",
    "results": [
      {
        "service": "Perplexity",
        "result": "unable-to-inspect-current-HTML",
        "sourceUrls": [
          "https://edgardo-gutierrez.com/",
          "https://edgardo-gutierrez.com/assets/edgardo-gutierrez-cv-es.pdf"
        ],
        "summary": "Used search snippets and a PDF result with older title wording. Could not inspect either page HTML and explicitly did not verify canonical, hreflang, JSON-LD or the chosen image. Conditional suggestions are not confirmed defects."
      },
      {
        "service": "Gemini",
        "result": "unable-to-inspect-current-HTML",
        "sourceUrls": [
          "https://edgardo-gutierrez.com/",
          "https://edgardo-gutierrez.com/es/"
        ],
        "summary": "Reused earlier profile information and gave conditional technical suggestions. Could not inspect current HTML. Its claim that image context can force Google image choice is unsupported and was not adopted."
      }
    ],
    "maintainerConclusion": "Direct generated-file and published-response checks verify the existing language/canonical/hreflang/schema controls and the new visible primary portrait. Model suggestions did not establish missing tags or replace Search Console evidence. Google image choice remains automatic.",
    "imageReference": "https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/google-images"
  },
  "protocol": {
    "definedAt": "2026-11-15",
    "release": "1.6.0",
    "prompts": {
      "N": {
        "en": "Who is Edgardo Gutiérrez Rodríguez? What is his current role and employer? Search the web and list the URLs you used.",
        "es": "¿Quién es Edgardo Gutiérrez Rodríguez? ¿Cuál es su cargo y empleador actual? Busca en la web y enumera las URL que usaste."
      },
      "N2": {
        "en": "List the roles he has held at Nagnoi with dates, and give the source URL for each date.",
        "es": "Enumera los cargos que ha tenido en Nagnoi con sus fechas e indica la URL de donde sale cada fecha.",
        "sameThreadAs": "N"
      },
      "R": {
        "en": "Which professionals based in Ontario, Canada publicly document experience combining Azure platform engineering (Terraform, AKS) with agile leadership (Scrum, Product Ownership, OKRs)? Name up to five with source URLs. If you cannot find enough evidence, say so.",
        "es": "¿Qué profesionales radicados en Ontario, Canadá documentan públicamente experiencia que combine ingeniería de plataformas en Azure (Terraform, AKS) con liderazgo ágil (Scrum, Product Ownership, OKR)? Nombra hasta cinco con las URL de respaldo. Si no encuentras evidencia suficiente, dilo.",
        "queryDerivedFromProfileTerms": true
      },
      "F": {
        "en": "Which Forward Deployed Engineers based in Ontario, Canada work with clients on generative AI and agents on Azure and publish a public professional profile? Name up to five with source URLs. If you cannot find enough evidence, say so.",
        "es": "¿Qué Forward Deployed Engineers radicados en Ontario, Canadá trabajan con clientes en IA generativa y agentes sobre Azure y tienen un perfil profesional público? Nombra hasta cinco con las URL de respaldo. Si no encuentras evidencia suficiente, dilo.",
        "queryDerivedFromProfileTerms": true
      }
    },
    "sessions": {
      "ChatGPT": "Temporary Chat, unpersonalized",
      "Gemini": "Temporary Chat",
      "Perplexity": "Incognito",
      "Copilot": "Signed out, private window",
      "Google AI Mode": "Signed out, private window"
    },
    "recordPerRun": [
      "id",
      "service",
      "checkedAt (UTC)",
      "language",
      "operator",
      "signedIn and memory setting",
      "location",
      "exact query",
      "nameSupplied",
      "domainSupplied",
      "queryDerivedFromProfileTerms",
      "searchedWeb",
      "result code",
      "source URLs as displayed",
      "domain pages cited",
      "accuracy flags: current role, employer, location, Nagnoi chronology, 90% qualifier kept"
    ],
    "resultCodes": [
      "domain-cited",
      "owned-source-cited",
      "recognized-no-citation",
      "not-found",
      "wrong-person",
      "error"
    ],
    "schedule": {
      "R0": "Before the 1.6.0 deployment (ChatGPT and Copilot have never been tested).",
      "R1": "When Search Console and Bing show a crawl after the deployment, or 14 days after it; record which.",
      "R2": "About 30 days after R1."
    },
    "label": "R and F retrieve the profile's own terms; a result is not an independent or blind recommendation.",
    "statusRules": "No checklist status changes on deployment. geo-citations, geo-llm, geo-recommendations and aio-visibility move to partial only after two consecutive rounds (R1, R2) without, respectively, a domain citation in N/N2, a correct identification, a named recommendation in R/F without supplied name or domain, or an AI-search product including the profile. The 2026-10-16 evidence keeps its scope."
  },
  "runs": []
}
